All-Star Game Format
| YEAR | HOST | FORMAT |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 | Event was not held | |
| 2020 | Wichita | Eastern Conference/Western Conference/Team Bolts/Team Hammers |
| 2019 | Toledo | Eastern Conference/Western Conference/Team Hooks/Team Fins |
| 2018 | Indy | North Division/South Division/Central Division/Mountain Division |
| 2017 | Adirondack | ECHL All-Stars vs. Adirondack Thunder |
| 2016 | Event was not held | |
| 2015 | Orlando | ECHL All-Stars vs. Orlando Solar Bears |
| 2014 | Event was not held | |
| 2013 | Colorado | ECHLL All-Stars vs. Colorado Eagles |
| 2012 | Event was not held | |
| 2011 | Bakersfield | ECHL All-Stars vs. Bakersfield Condors |
| 2010 | Ontario | American Conference vs. National Conference |
| 2009 | Reading | American Conference vs. National Conference |
| 2008 | Stockton | American Conference vs. National Conference |
| 2007 | Idaho | American Conference vs. National Conference |
| 2006 | Fresno | American Conference vs. National Conference |
| 2005 | Reading | American Conference vs. National Conference |
| 2004 | Peoria | Eastern Conference vs. Western Conference |
| 2003 | Florida | Northern Conference vs. Southern Conference |
| 2002 | Trenton | Northern Conference vs. Southern Conference |
| 2001 | Arkansas | Northern Conference vs. Southern Conference |
| 2000 | Greenville | Northern Conference vs. Southern Conference |
| 1999 | Mississippi | Northern Conference vs. Southern Conference |
| 1998 | Louisiana | Canada vs. USA/World |
| 1997 | Charlotte | ECHL All-Stars vs. Charlotte Checkers |
| 1996 | Tallahassee | North Division vs. South Division |
| 1995 | Greensboro | East Division vs. West Division |
| 1994 | Hampton Roads | East Division vs. West Division |
| 1993 | Wheeling | East Division vs. West Division |