| YEAR | PLAYER | TEAM |
| | |
| 2017 | Matt Register | Colorado Eagles |
| | |
| 2016 | Chad Costello | Allen Americans |
| | |
| 2015 | Greger Hanson | Allen Americans |
| | |
| 2014 | Rob Madore | Cincinnati Cyclones |
| | |
| 2013 | Riley Gill | Reading Royals |
| | |
| 2012 | John Muse | Florida Everblades |
| | |
| 2011 | Scott Howes | Alaska Aces |
| | |
| 2010 | Jeremy Smith and Robert Mayer | Cincinnati Cyclones |
| | |
| 2009 | James Reimer | South Carolina Stingrays |
| | |
| 2008 | Cedrick Desjardins | Cincinnati Cyclones |
| | |
| 2007 | Steve Silverthorn | Idaho Steelheads |
| | |
| 2006 | Mike Scott | Alaska Aces |
| | |
| 2005 | Leon Hayward | Trenton Titans |
| | |
| 2004 | Dan Ellis | Idaho Steelheads |
| | |
| 2003 | Kevin Colley | Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies |
| | |
| 2002 | Simon Gamache and Tyrone Garner | Greenville Grrrowl |
| | |
| 2001 | Dave Seitz | South Carolina Stingrays |
| | |
| 2000 | J.F. Boutin and Jason Christie | Peoria Rivermen |
| | |
| 1999 | Travis Scott | Mississippi Sea Wolves |
| | |
| 1998 | Sebastien Charpentier | Hampton Roads Admirals |
| | |
| 1997 | Jason Fitzsimmons | South Carolina Stingrays |
| | |
| 1996 | Nick Vitucci | Charlotte Checkers |
| | |
| 1995 | Blaine Moore | Richmond Renegades |
| | |
| 1994 | Dave Gagnon | Toledo Storm |
| | |
| 1993 | Rick Judson | Toledo Storm |
| | |
| 1992 | Mark Bernard | Hampton Roads Admirals |
| | |
| 1991 | Dave Flanagan and Dave Gagnon | Hampton Roads Admirals |
| | |
| 1990 | Wade Flaherty | Greensboro Monarchs |
| | |
| 1989 | Nick Vitucci | Carolina Thunderbirds |
