2018    Michael Joly, Colorado Eagles

2017    Matt Register, Colorado Eagles

2016    Chad Costello, Allen Americans

2015    Greger Hanson, Allen Americans

2014    Rob Madore, Cincinnati Cyclones

2013    Riley Gill, Reading Royals

2012    John Muse, Florida Everblades

2011    Scott Howes, Alaska Aces

2010    Jeremy Smith and Robert Mayer, Cincinnati Cyclones

2009    James Reimer, South Carolina Stingrays

2008    Cedrick Desjardins, Cincinnati Cyclones

2007    Steve Silverthorn, Idaho Steelheads

2006    Mike Scott, Alaska Aces

2005    Leon Hayward, Trenton Titans

2004    Dan Ellis, Idaho Steelheads

2003    Kevin Colley, Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies

2002    Simon Gamache and Tyrone Garner, Greenville Grrrowl

2001    Dave Seitz, South Carolina Stingrays

2000    Jason Christie and J.F. Boutin, Peoria Rivermen

1999    Travis Scott, Mississippi Sea Wolves

1998    Sebastien Charpentier, Hampton Roads Admirals

1997    Jason Fitzsimmons, South Carolina Stingrays

1996    Nick Vitucci, Charlotte Checkers

1995    Blaine Moore, Richmond Renegades

1994    Dave Gagnon, Toledo Storm

1993    Rick Judson, Toledo Storm

1992    Mark Bernard, Hampton Roads Admirals

1991    Dave Flanagan and Dave Gagnon, Hampton Roads Admirals

1990    Wade Flaherty, Greensboro Monarchs

1989    Nick Vitucci, Carolina Thunderbirds